Refutation of The Alleged Internal Contradictions in Quran : Will there be Inquiry in Paradise?

August 22, 2024 rezaervani Al Quran dan Orientalis, English Article, Refutation of The Alleged Internal Contradictions in the Quran 0



Refutation of The Alleged Internal Contradictions in Quran

Will there be Inquiry in Paradise?

All articles of Refutation of The Alleged Internal Contradictions in Quran is in can be read here 

Concerning the seventeenth alleged contradiction,

Will there be inquiry in Paradise? “neither will they question one another” [23:101] but nevertheless they will be “engaging in mutual inquiry” [52:25], “and they will … question one another” [37:27].

Verses in question,

23:101 Then, when the Trumpet is blown, there will be no kinship among them that Day, nor will they ask of one another

And 52:25 in context is:

52:21,22,25-28 And those who believe and whose offspring follow them in Faith, to them shall We join their offspring, and We shall not decrease the reward of their deeds in anything. Every person is a pledge for that which he has earned. And We shall provide them with fruit and meat, such as they desire….And some of them draw near to others, questioning.

Saying: “Aforetime, we were afraid with our families (from the punishment of Allâh). But Allâh has been gracious to us, and has saved us from the torment of the Fire. Verily, We used to invoke Him (Alone and none else) before. Verily, He is Al Barr the Most Generous, the Most Merciful.”

And 37:27 in context is:

37:22,23,27-33. (It will be said to the angels): “Assemble those who did wrong, together with their companions (from the devils) and what they used to worship, instead of Allâh, and lead them on to the way of flaming Fire (Hell);
And they will turn to one another and question one another.


They will say: “It was you who used to come to us from the right side.”
They will reply: “Nay, you yourselves were not believers. And we had no authority over you. Nay! But you were transgressing people (disobedient, polytheists, and disbelievers). So now the Word of our Lord has been justified against us, that we shall certainly (have to) taste (the torment).So we led you astray because we were ourselves astray.”


Then verily, that Day, they will (all) share in the torment.

1. The first point that becomes obvious here, once the context is added, is that these verses are not referring to the same event. Verse 23:101 states that on the Day of Judgement, after the trumpet, no one will ask eachother for help. They will stand silently before their Lord, to be judged.
Meanwhile, verse 52:25 states that in paradise, the reward for the believers will include anything they desire, and they shall engage in mutual discussion. This obviously is not a reference to the Day of resurrection.
Likewise, verse 37:27 speaks of the disbelievers who will dispute with eachother about who is to blame for their terrible fate. This is obvious from the mentioning of assembling those who did wrong, and leading them to Hell-fire. Evidently, this would occur after the Day of Judgement.
2. The second point is that there is a different understanding of what is being asked in each verse. Verse 23:101 refers to the fact that they will not be able to ask eachother for help. Here, “ask” is understood to be a request. Verse 52:25 refers to the fact that they will engage in mutual discussion. Here “ask” is understood to be general inquiry and discussion, not a request. And finally, verse 37:27 refers to the disputes that will be held by the people of Hell-fire. here “ask” refers to harsh interrogation and argumentation, not a request. This is supported by the understanding of the arabic verb used, yatasa’aloon.


Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.